What the burner assembly includes
On a gas tank heater, the burner assembly sits behind a small access door at the bottom. It includes the burner itself, the pilot or igniter, the thermocouple that senses the flame and the gas control valve that opens and closes the gas. Many "burner problems" turn out to be a dirty pilot, a failed thermocouple or a faulty control valve, not the burner itself.
Each part has a different cost, so the first step is a diagnosis. Cleaning the burner, replacing a thermocouple and replacing the gas control valve are three different jobs with three different price levels. A technician should tell you which part failed before quoting.
Common failures and what they usually involve
| Symptom | Likely part | Typical remedy |
|---|---|---|
| Pilot will not stay lit | Thermocouple or dirty pilot | Clean or replace the thermocouple. |
| Burner will not ignite | Igniter, gas valve or no gas | Test and replace the failed part. |
| Yellow, lazy flame | Dirty burner or poor air supply | Clean the burner and check combustion air. |
| Burner runs but water stays cool | Sediment layer or failed thermostat | Flush the tank and test the control. |
| Rumble or pop noises | Sediment on the tank bottom | Flush or consider replacement. |
| Soot on the tank bottom | Poor combustion | Stop using it and have it inspected. |
Soot, a strong gas smell or carbon monoxide alarms are safety problems. Turn off the gas, ventilate and call the gas utility or 911 before you call a plumber.
What drives the cost of burner work
These factors set the price.
Repair or replace: the age rule
A common rule of thumb says that if the heater is over 10 years old and the repair is more than half the price of a new heater, replace it. The tank is the part that you cannot repair, and an old tank can fail soon after a repair. A heater under 8 years old with a failed burner part is usually worth fixing.
Consider what else you will do. A replacement is the time to move to a more efficient model, to add a drain pan and an expansion tank, and to bring the install up to current code. See water heater replacement and water heater repair to compare the two paths.
Want a plumber to handle it?
Call and a person answers, any hour. You hear the price before any work starts.
A Milpitas rule that affects the decision
The Bay Area Air Quality Management District has adopted zero-NOx limits for new gas water heaters. The date for new gas tank water heaters has been delayed to 2028, according to the district. That delay means a gas tank is still available to buy in Milpitas today, but the future points to electric and heat pump models.
A burner repair on a gas heater that is still sound extends its life without forcing that choice.
The City of Milpitas also requires a plumbing permit to replace a water heater, with seismic strapping, a relief valve discharge and a seismic gas shutoff valve where required. A burner repair on an existing heater is a repair, not a replacement, so the permit is typically not needed.
Check with the city if the repair involves moving or changing the vent. For homes in North San Jose, see our San Jose service page.
Source type: BAAQMD notices on Rule 9-6 and City of Milpitas Office of Building Safety handout.
What a diagnosis visit looks like
Safety check
We test for gas leaks and check for carbon monoxide.
Inspect the burner and pilot
We look at the flame, the igniter and the thermocouple.
Test the gas control
A meter or manometer confirms the valve and thermostat work.
Check the tank
Rust, leaks and sediment are noted.
Present options
You hear the repair cost, the replacement cost and our view of each.
Safety signs that mean stop and call
- A smell of gas near the heaterLeave the house and call the gas utility or 911.
- Soot or scorch marks around the burner doorCombustion is not clean.
- A carbon monoxide alarm soundsGet everyone outside and call for help.
- Orange or yellow flame with a lazy shapeThe burner needs cleaning or the air supply is blocked.
- Water pooling at the baseA tank leak means replacement, not a burner repair.
What to do before you call
Check that the gas valve to the heater is open and that the thermostat is set above the cold setting. Look for a tripped breaker if your heater has an electronic igniter. Do not take apart the gas control yourself. If you smell gas, leave the house and call the gas utility or 911.
We can diagnose your heater by phone first. Call (510) 544-1962 and tell us what the heater does and how old it is, and we tell you what to expect.
Common Questions
It depends on which part failed and the model. We diagnose first and give you a price before work begins.
Usually not if the repair is major. The tank is near the end of its life, and replacement is often a better value.
A worn thermocouple, a dirty pilot tube or a draft are the usual causes.
A repair of an existing heater generally does not. A replacement does.
Leave gas control work to a professional. Gas leaks and carbon monoxide are serious risks.
